Is Theresa May about to Cry “Mayday”?
British newspapers on 1/16/2019 © Lenscap Photography / Shutterstock
Theresa May has tried one more time after trying again and again, and to her surprise, she has failed yet again.
British Prime Minister Theresa May appears mystified. But at least, after so many attempts, she is now in a position to tell us why everyone else is wrong and how pitiful the outcome will be.
“Look around the world,” she commands us, “and consider the health of liberal democratic politics, and look across the United Kingdom and consider the impact of failing to deliver on the clear instruction of the British people in a lawful [Brexit] referendum.”
Here is today’s 3D definition:
1) The transmission of knowledge acquired through study and experience from those who know for the benefit of those who need to learn
2) In UK politics: A one-word command issued by a group of people who, before expressing the command, had no means of studying or understanding the issue or its consequences
May’s sentence, in itself, is a “clear instruction” or command. She tells her listeners to “look” at things, first “around the world” and then “across the United Kingdom.” Her eyes have long been open, theirs closed.
At this point — nearly two months since the official but unrespected cutoff date for leaving the European Union on March 29 — her critics might counter: It is indeed time to take a good look around, but why did no one have the time to do that three years ago?
The traditional proverb instructs people to “look before you leap,” but May’s colleague and predecessor, David Cameron, foolishly asked the nation to leap before it looked. As the Brits approach the cliff, Prime Minister May keeps reminding them that they are legally committed to leaping.
In the nearly three years since the referendum on leaving the EU, people have been looking, and more particularly observing, what May herself has done… or not done.
Those who have looked will have noticed by now that the fateful Brexit vote was indeed a game-changer, though in ways no one expected.
It may have been “a lawful referendum” insofar as it didn’t violate any law, yet in terms of defining a course of action, it was anything but a “clear instruction.”
By looking around, May correctly perceives symptoms of the failing health of “liberal democratic politics,” but the pathology took root long before the 2016 referendum, not because of it. Nor is it the result of the hopelessly confused attempt, by the prime minister and the entire political class, to manage its consequences.
She also correctly identifies it as a global rather than just a British problem.
Though no two people at random are ly to agree on the definition of “liberal democracy,” and many might even wonder if it is worth defending, most observers realize that wherever you look today, especially in the traditional bastions of Western democracy, something seems to be going wrong — though not necessarily quite on the same scale as in the UK, where “going awry” might be a more appropriate choice of vocabulary.
May’s political conscience — her Freudian superego — appears to be telling her she and the nation have failed “to deliver.” As if her government was Amazon and had just registered an online order from a consumer for immediate shipping.
The package appears to have been lost in the post. That tells us more about her own definition of “liberal democracy” than her protests about respecting a lawful referendum.
May perhaps envisions her own historic role as little more than a glorified delivery service.
The prime minister regrets having to propose a second referendum on Brexit because she believes “we should be implementing the result of the first referendum.” She attributes the necessity to allow for a second referendum as part of her new offer to the “strength of feeling across” the House of Commons.
This implies that she sees herself as the rational, pragmatic leader (Freud’s ego) trying to manage the impulses or feelings of the devils in Parliament (Britain’s id): the unrepentant remainers who voted to stay in the EU. After all, May herself is a reformed remainer, who for over two years has desperately wanted to show her willingness to magnanimously sacrifice her own initial inclinations to please “the people.”
But May has discovered devils in her own party, ready to turn up the heat of their hellfire as soon as she even hints at making any concession to the remainers.
One of the current devils is Harlow MP Robert Halfon, a fellow Tory who, manifestly upset at her suggestion that a second referendum may be necessary, sees his prime minister and party leader as a traitor to the sacred cause she herself continues to defend verbally: “This is a betrayal of the 2016 referendum and a betrayal of everything she has been saying since she became prime minister.”
And so it goes in the hyperreal drama called Brexit. The BBC calls May’s latest offer “a last roll of the dice.
” Trying to please all the unhappy groups that had previously opposed her deal, in the “strange complex process” she has cobbled together, Theresa May hopes, in the words of the BBC, “to dangle a bauble to each of Parliament’s different Brexit tribes.
” Their various reactions show that all they saw were the baubles offered to their own opponents as well as the obvious contradictions among the baubles.
Few, however, complained when she reminded them that she had “offered to give up the job I love earlier than I would .” If she really does love her job, the Freudians might take it for the confession of a masochist.
The Times comments: “[I]n truth the job gave up on her long ago.” Apparently, she hadn’t noticed.
She must have been looking “around the world” or “across the United Kingdom” instead of focusing on what was happening in front of her very eyes in Westminster.
*[In the age of Oscar Wilde and Mark Twain, another American wit, the journalist Ambrose Bierce, produced a series of satirical definitions of commonly used terms, throwing light on their hidden meanings in real discourse.
Bierce eventually collected and published them as a book, The Devil’s Dictionary, in 1911.
We have shamelessly appropriated his title in the interest of continuing his wholesome pedagogical effort to enlighten generations of readers of the news.]
The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Fair Observer’s editorial policy.
Opinion today: Theresa May’s final roll of the dice
This article is from today’s FT Opinion email. Sign up to receive a daily digest of the big issues straight to your inbox.
The crushing rejection of prime minister Theresa May’s Brexit deal by Parliament this week was hardly a surprise. Yet, despite the fact that the deal’s rejection was both predictable and predicted, the scale of the defeat still managed to shock pundits and political observers.
This has been a characteristic of the Brexit process at every stage along the way so far, observes Philip Stephens in his column. The impact has been cumulative: chapter after chapter of humiliation in a story of national shame. It is hard to see how even the damage done so far can be repaired.
Just weeks before Britain’s scheduled departure from the EU, Mrs May’s authority is broken, the opposition cannot pass a vote of no-confidence against her government, and the MPs who threw out her plan have no shared alternative. If she is to salvage anything from this week’s wreckage Mrs May must now set aside her vanity to behave as a prime minister rather than a party leader, Philip notes. Many fear she is too small a politician for the task.
Janan Ganesh posits that it is timefor America to embrace a class struggle. In a country riven along the lines of race, gender and sexuality, this fracture feel less fraught.
Marietje Schaake, a Dutch MEP,warns that Germany’s recent data hack should be a wake-up call to all Europeans, especially in the run up to the European elections in May.
Frederick Studemann discusses the unsettling problem for Europeans living in the UK who, him, face applying for settled status in a place they already call home.
Eric Jing explains how responsible technology can transform millions of lives. The head of Ant Financial says that, by being creative, groups his can work together to benefit the underprivileged.
David Gardner argues that by withdrawing US forces from Syria, the Trump administration is making the most consistently combustible region in the world more explosive.
What you’ve been saying
Data harvesting in the days of direct mail, letter from Marco Bueninck, Mexico City, Mexico.
After reading the article about data brokers ( “The data merchants”, FT Big Read, January 9), I think with melancholy back to the days I ran the subscription department for a renowned publisher in Amsterdam.
Twice a year we sent out, all over Europe, millions of direct mail letters to sell our subscriptions.
The objective was simple: increase our circulation and attract more advertisers…And yes, we got complaints from some people.
In response to, Theresa May has one last throw of the Brexit dice, Wlkrrch says:
Over the course of several decades Tories wove an entirely imaginary vision of a monstrous European tyranny myriad small and mostly insignificant snippets of mundane everyday bureaucratic idiocy, and as the tapestry grew the colours became more and more vivid until the keepers of the vision could compare the EU to the USSR and Nazi Germany with a straight face and without blushing.
Clarity and independence matter for British workers, letter from Simon Brewer, London, UK.
What Sunderland’s Nissan voters always suspected. Liberal amazement abounded when communities such as Sunderland voted to leave. How could they endanger their livelihoods was the question asked, frequently with derision. Perhaps they suspected that for all their hard work and professionalism, if you play with a biased referee, you will often lose, despite your best efforts.
Lex: BofA/Goldman Sachs: dove tail risk
Shareholders worry that a slowing US economy will stall banks’ profit expansion
Lex: DSV/Panalpina: easy ascent
Analysts note higher savings are possible, suggesting Swiss group’s suitor could pay more
Lex: Brexit crisis/gilts: sound despite fury
The odds are surely narrowing that the UK remains in the EU
FT Magazine: Legalising marijuana in the US: the economic highs (and lows)
Wall Street is rushing into a field already worth an estimated $10bn
Lex: Santander/Orcel: no we cannot
Spanish bank may have dodged a bullet over lost pay from UBS
Brexit: the unsettling business of applying for ‘settled status’
UK government is forcing a choice that many of us never wanted to make
Lex: Reckitt Benckiser/Rakesh Kapoor: brand groupie
Replacing admirable chief Rakesh Kapoor will be tough
Time for America to embrace the class struggle
This faultline feels less fraught than rifts over race, gender and sexuality
Responsible technology can transform millions of lives
By being creative, groups can work together to benefit the world’s underprivileged
Dear Jonathan: I am 67: how do I sell my age and experience to an employer?
Your questions for our expert — and readers’ advice
Germany’s data hack is a wake-up call to Europe
The digital security of all in the political system must be tightened ahead of elections
FT Alphaville: America has never worried about financing its priorities
Theresa May has one last throw of the Brexit dice
She should set aside her vanity and behave as a prime minister not a party leader
US withdrawal from Syria will remove restraints
Trump is making the most consistently combustible region in the world more explosive
Frequent flyer: Herb Kelleher and compassion in the air
In the joyless business of flying, airline staff are our allies, not our enemies
Free Lunch: Theresa May is a lightning rod for Brexit denials
Defeat of withdrawal deal does not change realities confronting the UK
The Art of Persuasion: Theresa May’s speech could not persuade the unpersuadable
The prime minister deployed clever rhetorical tricks but her appeal to MPs was doomed
Supporting animal charities can be far more than a pet project
Cats and dogs command huge donations — but other causes may deliver more lasting good
FT Magazine: Open-plan offices: time to bring back the cubicle?
‘From Reddit to Apple, tech offices all share an antipathy towards walls’
Cleaning up: the peculiar power of Marie Kondo
Not everyone is bewitched by the decluttering guru — but she’s done wonders for my drawers
New investors: don’t be afraid to ask stupid questions
For beginners, the world of investment is a minefield of jargon
FTfm: Big data to boost prospects for female star managers
FT Alphaville: Was AMLOve just EM investors’ summer fling?
Markets Insight: Why this year won’t be a rerun of 2016 for emerging markets
Policymakers will be mindful of the risk of fear feeding on itself
Lex: Provident Financial: tight rope act
FCA’s crackdown must also balance out needs of those at lower end of credit spectrum
Instant Insight: Theresa May’s drubbing points to a Brexit delay
A soft exit from the EU now looks more ly
Lombard: Online retailer Boohoo.com cheers up after Asos sales upset
Results stand in contrast to online rivals but investors should keep eye on certain metrics
The FT View: Theresa May must put country before party to fix Brexit
A non-partisan approach is needed to avoid the chaos of a no-deal exit from the EU
The FT View: Tragic murder in Gdansk is a warning for Europe
Pawel Adamowicz had become a symbol of tolerant liberalism
The Big Read
The Big Read: Spain wrestles with a private equity boom
Crisis-era reforms have made it a target for investors looking to cut costs — and jobs